Most Active Stories
- Why Teacher Pay Matters Even If You Are Not a Teacher [Interactive Map]
- Suspects In Mugging Death Of UNC Chapel Hill Professor Charged With Murder
- Carl Kasell Helps With Surprise Marriage Proposal
- Sixth-Grader's Science Project Catches Ecologists' Attention
- A Portrait Photographer Defies Social Norms
Hosts, Reporters and Producers
Shots - Health News
Tue August 13, 2013
Obamacare: People With Disabilities Face Complex Choices
Originally published on Thu August 15, 2013 7:59 am
The Affordable Care Act has set new standards — called essential health benefits — outlining what health insurance companies must now cover. But there's a catch: Insurance firms can still pick and choose, to some degree, which specific therapies they'll cover within some categories of benefit. And the way insurers interpret the rules could turn out to be a big deal for people with disabilities who need ongoing therapy.
Bryce Vernon is a 20-year-old film student who lives in Los Angeles and has cerebral palsy. He speaks only with the aid of a special computer that is mounted to his wheelchair and tracks his eye movements. Using his eyes, Vernon can indicate on a screen which letters and words he wants the computer's voice to say.
It's amazing technology, and Vernon gets a lot more out of it with help from speech-language pathologist Jill Tullman.
"Now Bryce, I want to show you this super cool random button I think you're going to love," Tullman tells him during a therapy session at a special camp for young people who use the technology. Vernon's parents paid out-of-pocket for him to attend the camp.
Tullman helps him pre-load several different ways of saying goodbye.
"Bye, later dude, later, bye, I'm out of here, see ya later," Vernon says, testing it out.
In the parlance of health policy, the work Tullman is doing with Vernon is called "habilitative services." It's different from the more familiar sort of rehab people often get after an injury or surgery. Habilitative services are for people who can benefit from one-on-one time with a therapist to improve daily living skills. But such services can be expensive and not all insurance plans have covered them.
The Affordable Care Act is changing that, says health economist Lisa Clemans-Cope, a health economist with the Urban Institute.
"You're much more likely to find these benefits in a plan in the individual market [starting in 2014] than you would be today — far more likely," says Clemans-Cope.
Far more likely because "habilitative services" is included within the 10 categories of essential health benefits the ACA will require in those new plans. Still, while some categories are straightforward — such as maternity care, drug abuse treatment and preventive care — the category including habilitative services leaves more room for interpretation.
For instance, insurers could choose to cover physical therapy for someone with a broken bone, but not cover long-term support services for chronic conditions, such as speech therapy for kids with developmental delays.
Clemans-Cope says some insurers may arrange their benefits in a way that discourages people with expensive chronic conditions from signing up with them. And, she says, people who want specific therapies covered are going to have to slog through some fine print to figure out if they'll actually benefit from a particular policy. (The new policies will start to go on sale this fall, and go into effect beginning Jan. 1, 2014.)
"This is a big improvement, but we should emphasize that it's not totally fixed," Clemans-Cope says. "And people are really going to have to get help to decide which plans cover the benefits they need. "
Whether a person will be able to get the new therapy benefits also depends on where they live. The level of benefits that insurers have to provide in each category is based on a model policy in each state, and some of those policies are a lot more generous than others.
Jill Tappert, an activist in Colorado for people with disabilities, says a lot of details still need to be sorted out before she'll be able to say whether the health care law has improved things much.
"I certainly hope the way the Affordable Care Act is implemented is a game changer for people in the disabilities community. It can be," says Tappert, who spent years fighting for habilitative service coverage for her daughter who has autism. "The opportunity is there for policy makers to vastly improve lives."
Barbara Vernon, Bryce's mother, says Bryce is now covered by Medi-Cal, California's Medicaid program. His primary insurance had been her employer-sponsored plan until she was laid off in 2009. She searched for private coverage for Bryce, she says, but "private insurance was so unbelievably expensive, it was unafforadable."
Vernon says her family's health insurance is "a patchwork," with Bryce likely to stay on Medi-Cal even after his 21st birthday. She and her other son have an individual plan they have purchased, and her husband has an employer-sponsored plan that only covers the employee — not the family.
For his part, Bryce Vernon says his life is a lot better since getting the kind of help that many others may be able to get from the health law, starting in 2014. He works hard to get the most out of the technology and the therapy that lets him speak. His advice to others: "Never, ever give up."
The new rules for what health insurance companies must cover may still change. Federal regulators plan to review them as the health law rolls out, and could make changes in 2016.
This piece is part of a reporting partnership among NPR, Colorado Public Radio and Kaiser Health News.
RENEE MONTAGNE, HOST:
The Affordable Care Act will require most Americans to have health insurance by the beginning of next year. The law also sets standards for what that health insurance must cover. That's potentially a big deal for people with disabilities.
The law could help thousands get therapies they can't get now to help with daily living. Still, the insurance companies have a lot of discretion as to what to cover, as Colorado Public Radio's Eric Whitney reports.
ERIC WHITNEY, BYLINE: For 20-year-old film student Bryce Vernon, time with speech language pathologist Jill Tullman is golden.
JILL TULLMAN: Now, Bryce, I want to show you this super cool, random button that I think you're going to love.
WHITNEY: Vernon has cerebral palsy. He speaks but only with the aid of a special computer that tracks his eye movements, allowing him to select letters and icons on a screen mounted to his wheelchair.
BRYCE VERNON: My name is Bryce Vernon. I live in Los Angeles.
WHITNEY: It's amazing technology. and Vernon gets a lot more out of it with Tullman's help. Today, at a special camp for kids who use this technology, she's helping him pre-load several different ways of saying goodbye.
VERNON: Later, dude, later. Bye. I'm out of here.
TULLMAN: Isn't that fun?
VERNON: See you later.
WHITNEY: Lots of people like Vernon could benefit from one-on-one time with a therapist to improve their daily living skills. But it's expensive and not all insurance plans cover it. The Affordable Care Act is changing that, says health economist Lisa Clemans-Cope, with the Urban Institute.
LISA CLEMANS-COPE: You're much more likely to find these benefits in a plan after 2014 in the individual market, than you would be today - far more likely.
WHITNEY: Far more likely because the health law now requires insurance companies to cover 10 categories of services they didn't have to before. Some are straightforward like maternity care, drug abuse treatment and preventive care. But other categories are broader, like the one that includes some services Vernon needs. And insurance companies can pick and choose which specific therapies they'll cover in each category.
For instance, physical therapy benefits to recover from broken bones can be much more generous than therapies for long-term help for chronic conditions, like speech therapy for kids with cerebral palsy. Clemans-Cope says some insurers may arrange their benefits in a way that discourages people with expensive conditions from signing up with them. And she says people who want specific therapies covered are going have to slog through some fine print, to see if they'll actually benefit from the new policies for sale in 2014.
CLEMANS-COPE: This is a big improvement, but we should emphasize that it's not totally fixed. And people are really going to have to get help, to help them decide which plans cover the benefits they need.
WHITNEY: Whether a person will be able to get the new therapy benefits also depends on where they live. The level of benefits insurers have to provide in each category is based on a model policy in each state, and some are a lot more generous than others.
Activists for the disabled, like Jill Tappert in Colorado, say a lot of details still need to be sorted out, before they'll be able to say whether the health care law has changed things much.
JILL TAPPERT: I certainly hope that the way the Affordable Care Act is implemented is a game changer for individual in the disabilities community - it can be. The opportunity is there for policymakers to vastly improve lives.
WHITNEY: Bryce Vernon says his life is a lot better since getting the kind of help that many others may be able to get from the health law in 2014. He works hard to get the most out of the technology and therapy that let him speak.
VERNON: Never, ever give up.
WHITNEY: The new rules for what health insurance companies have to cover can be changed. Federal regulators plan to review them as the health law rolls out, and could make changes in 2016.
For NPR News, I'm Eric Whitney in Denver.
MONTAGNE: That story is part of collaboration, among NPR, Colorado Public Radio and Kaiser Health News.
(SOUNDBITE OF MUSIC)
MONTAGNE: This is NPR News.
(SOUNDBITE OF MUSIC) Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.