News
5:25 am
Sat June 8, 2013

NSA Scandal Looms Over Obama's Talks With China's Xi

Originally published on Sun June 9, 2013 5:39 am

President Obama always intended to talk about spying this weekend. But not like this.

He's getting to know China's new leader at a sprawling estate in the Southern California desert this weekend, but domestic controversies have followed him there.

The president veered off his talking points Friday to spend more than 10 minutes defending a pair of massive surveillance operations that the media recently disclosed.

One program gives the National Security Agency months of phone logs from Verizon. The other gives the government access to even more detailed information like photos and chat logs from internet giants including Google, Yahoo and Microsoft.

About that second program, Obama told members of the press, "This does not apply to U.S. citizens, and it does not apply to people living in the United States."

Some members of Obama's own party are now attacking him for overreaching, and civil liberties groups are comparing him unfavorably to President George W. Bush. So Obama was feeling the heat before he took off for Palm Springs.

Then he arrived in the desert, where the temperature hovered around 110 degrees.

"This is a wonderful place, a place of sunshine," said China's new president, Xi Jinping, through a translator.

He and Obama sat at a long table in open-collared shirts and dark suits, discussing what they both called a "new model" of cooperation between their countries.

Here's how Obama described his goals for the casual weekend summit:

"Our thought was that we would have the opportunity for a more extended, and more informal, conversation in which we were able to share both our visions for our respective countries and how we can forge a new model of cooperation between countries based on mutual interest and mutual respect."

As they work to find common ground, the U.S. and China are also wrestling with some major differences, from military disputes to global trade to cyber-espionage.

And that brings us back to the way Obama intended to discuss spying this weekend. Sitting across from Xi, he delicately alluded to American concerns that China is manipulating trade and sending hackers to infiltrate U.S. networks.

"The United States seeks an international economy and an international economic order where nations are playing by the same rules, where trade is free and fair, and where the United States and China work together to address issues like cybersecurity and the protection of intellectual property," Obama said.

The men spent about three hours talking with aides in private. Then, just before a working dinner, they took two questions from the media.

A Chinese reporter asked the leaders to describe the main areas of conversation and consensus, while an American reporter pointedly asked whether Obama warned Xi that cyberhacking would have consequences.

"We haven't had yet in-depth discussions about the cybersecurity issue," Obama answered. "We've been speaking at the 40,000-foot level."

And on government surveillance of Americans, Obama said, Americans volunteer a lot of this information daily.

"You've got private companies that have a lot more data and and a lot more details about emails and phone calls than the federal government does," he said.

This American-Chinese diplomatic dance is unfolding at a 200-acre estate called Sunnylands, full of man-made lakes and a private golf course. Xi and his entourage are not sleeping in the guest rooms, though.

The Chinese delegation decided to stay at a hotel nearby out of fear that the U.S. might be spying on them — a decision they made before this week's disclosures about American surveillance.

Copyright 2013 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

Transcript

SCOTT SIMON, HOST:

And this NSA controversy has followed the president to his meeting with the Chinese premier in California. They are holding talks in Palm Springs over the weekend but the uproar over the secret spying program threatens to overshadow the president's agenda, as NPR's Ari Shapiro reports.

ARI SHAPIRO, BYLINE: President Obama always intended to talk about spying this weekend but not like this.

PRESIDENT BARACK OBAMA: Nobody is listening to your telephone calls.

SHAPIRO: Yesterday morning, in Northern California, the president veered off his talking points to spend more than 10 minutes defending a pair of massive surveillance operations that the media recently disclosed. One program gives the National Security Agency months of phone logs from Verizon. The other gives the government access to even more detailed information like photos and chat logs from Internet giants including Google, Yahoo and Microsoft. About that second program, Obama said...

OBAMA: This does not apply to U.S. citizens, and it does not apply to people living in the United States.

SHAPIRO: Some members of President Obama's own party are now attacking him for overreaching, and civil liberties groups are comparing him unfavorably to President George W. Bush. So, President Obama was feeling the heat before he took off for Palm Springs. Then he arrived in the desert, where the temperature hovered around 110 degrees.

PRESIDENT XI JINPING: (Through translator) This is a wonderful place, a place of sunshine.

SHAPIRO: China's new president, Xi Jinping, spoke through a translator. He and President Obama sat at a long table in open-collared shirts and dark suits, discussing what they both called a new model of cooperation between their countries. Here's how Obama describes his goals for the casual weekend summit.

OBAMA: Our thought was that we would have the opportunity for a more extended and more informal conversation in which we were able to share both our visions for our respective countries and how we can forge a new model of cooperation between countries based on mutual interest and mutual respect.

SHAPIRO: As they work to find common ground, the U.S. and China are also wrestling with some major differences, from military disputes to global trade to cyber-espionage. And that brings us back to the way President Obama intended to discuss spying this weekend. Sitting across from Xi Jinping, he delicately alluded to American concerns that China is manipulating trade and sending hackers to infiltrate U.S. networks.

OBAMA: The United States seeks an international economy and an international economic order where nations are playing by the same rules, where trade is free and fair, and where the United States and China work together to address issues like cyber-security and the protection of intellectual property.

SHAPIRO: The men spent about three hours talking with aides in private. Then, just before a working dinner, they took two questions from the media. The Chinese reporter asked the leaders to describe the main areas of conversation and consensus. The American reporter pointedly asked whether Obama warned Xi that cyber-hacking would have consequences.

OBAMA: We haven't had yet in-depth discussions about the cyber-security issue. We're speaking at the 40,000-foot level.

SHAPIRO: And on government surveillance of Americans, Obama said in short, Americans volunteer a lot of this information daily.

OBAMA: Private companies that have a lot more data and a lot more details about people's emails and telephone calls than the federal government does.

SHAPIRO: This American-Chinese diplomatic dance is unfolding at a 200-acre estate called Sunnylands, full of man-made lakes and a private golf course. President Xi and his entourage are not sleeping in the guest rooms, though. The Chinese delegation decided to stay at a hotel nearby, out of fear that the U.S. might be spying on them - a decision they made before this week's disclosures about American surveillance. Ari Shapiro, NPR News, Palm Springs. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.

Related Program